Thursday, October 6, 2011

Journal #4

There is a buzz of a new technology that can be used instead of school books, called e-textbooks. E-textbooks are electronic text books that schools around America have been debating whether to use or not. This futuristic concept may seem efficient, although I question its effectiveness. Certain states in the U.S are coming to the conclusion too soon, that their schools should adapt this new way of learning. E-textbooks should be evaluated before being put into practice.
                Schools have been taking action too soon, when they found out about the electronic text books. “The Florida legislature passed a bill requiring the state’s schools to replace all paper textbooks with digital editions by 2016” states Carr in his article Schools, beware the e-book bandwagon. These measures are too drastic.  Carr also explains the differences between regular text books and e-books. While reading a regular text book, a reader has the freedom to read as they please; from jotting down notes on the pages to physically flipping back and forth through the pages. (With a normal text book,) “… adapts readily to whoever is holding it.” Whereas with the electronic book, the reader must adapt to it. Also, being an easy online access, things such as game advertisements, or Facebook become distractions to reading.  A student in a recent study simply explains, “E-books divide my attention.” During another study, a group of students were provided with Kindles in order to read. The Kindle stopped being used or was abandoned by nearly two-thirds of the students at the end of the school-year.
                The argument saying e-books are new, avant garde pieces of technology, still stands true. Carr states in his article, “They can be updated quickly with new information… They reduce paper and photocopier use. And they’re lightweight freeing students from the torso-straining load of book filled backpacks.” All this is true. If electronic books were being used, worldwide, it would be an international breakthrough. The use of paper would be scarce. Billions of pages for text books would not need to be printed. However, despite the wonders it would do for mother nature it is not worth it.
                I do not find electronic text books easy to study from. Personally, I can get very distracted. I find it easier for myself to be reading from a piece of paper in front of my own eyes; away from any internet distractions. I believe there are many other students like me, in this aspect. So if every state in America decides to get rid of traditional text books, many students will not be satisfied. Studying for ourselves, is a tedious, difficult task. With electronic text books, everything will become twice as hard as students will have to learn to adapt themselves to a new way of learning.
                Even though I do not believe in the universal use of electronic text books, I do find other technology useful to education today. For example, computers. There are many things we can do with computers, one being typing this response. Another being watching videos online, for a class like science. Previous years, I have done lab experiments online as well. Even though some ideas we learn about such as in science we cannot do hands on experiments in class, we use technology in order to watch videos about them, or do lab experiments. 

2 comments:

  1. This is a great response and you are a very talented writer! What English/Writing class are you in?

    ReplyDelete